Aaron Rodgers

Aaron Rodgers will be a first-ballot Hall-of-Famer, but how does his career line up with a QB who already dons the gold jacket?

#12, the Bad Man himself is undoubtedly the better quarterback. Elway is an NFL all-time great and deserves his place in the Hall of Fame, but when you compare him to Aaron Rodgers, the choice is clear. Even as Rodgers enters his age-38 season, he is still at the top of his game playing at an elite level. Packers fans will remember his clutch plays at the end of Super Bowl XXXII that denied Green Bay’s bid at a title. John Elway started 21 playoff games over the course of his career, going 14-7 in those games. If one simply looked at the raw stats, you might think Aaron Rodgers was far and away the better QB.